Craft Chat Chronicles
Craft Chat Chronicles
Season 4 Episode 4: Secrets of the Publishing World REVEALED by Agent-Turned-Author Rachel Ekstrom Courage!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Immerse yourself in our latest episode as we explore the intriguing journey of a literary agent turned author. This captivating discussion reveals firsthand insights on how the writing, publishing, and marketing landscape has evolved through the years. Our special guest dives into the unique challenges she faced while transitioning from a publicist to a successful literary agent and now an author, providing listeners with a rich appreciation for the multifaceted nature of storytelling.
Throughout the episode, we unearth valuable writing tips, such as how to craft the perfect query letter, common pitfalls to avoid, and the essential elements that make a compelling story hook. Our guest also shares her thoughts on current market trends in Young Adult and cozy mysteries, highlighting what resonates with readers today. With her fresh perspective, we gain insights into how authors can navigate the complexities of publishing and find their unique voices in a crowded literary landscape.
Join us as we discuss building suspense, creating believable characters, and the crafting of unforgettable narratives. The episode is brimming with practical advice and personal anecdotes, making it a must-listen for aspiring writers eager to embark on their own journeys in the literary world. With an engaging blend of storytelling and industry insight, we invite you to tune in, subscribe, and share your thoughts with us!
https://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener-affiliate.html?fpr=craftchat
Rachel Ekstrom Courage, literary agent tips, how to get published, query letter tips, writing advice, publishing industry secrets, cozy mystery market, young adult publishing trends, storytelling tips, book marketing hacks, how to land a literary agent, writing a bestseller, publishing journey, insider publishing tips, aspiring author guide, book industry trends, crafting compelling characters, writing unforgettable stories, building suspense in novels, agent-to-author transition, writing pitfalls to avoid, how to craft the perfect hook, selling your book idea, behind-the-scenes publishing, secrets to a successful book pitch
🎙️ Craft Chat Chronicles with J.D. Myall
Candid conversations on writing, publishing, and creative life — featuring bestselling authors, MFA students, and writers at every stage of the journey.
About J.D. Myall
J.D. Myall is the co-chair of Drexel University’s MFA Alumni Association and a publishing and library professional. She is the creator and host of Craft Chat Chronicles, where she interviews authors, agents, and industry insiders about the art and business of writing.
Her work has appeared in Ms. Magazine, Writer’s Digest, and HuffPost. Her debut novel, Heart’s Gambit, releases with Wednesday Books/Macmillan in February 2026.
When she’s not conjuring magic, murder, and mayhem on the page, J.D. mentors emerging writers through workshops and alumni programs, fostering community among aspiring and published authors alike.
💜 Connect with J.D. Myall
📸 Instagram
🌐 Website & Media Kit
💌 Newsletter
🔗 Linktree
Watch episodes on YouTube as well.
💜 Level up your writing process with Scrivener — the ...
Welcome to Craft Chat Chronicles
Speaker 1Welcome to Craft Chat Chronicles , the go-to podcast for tips on crafting best-selling fiction . Here at Craft Chat Chronicles , we bring you expert interviews , insights and tips on writing , publishing and marketing . Join the conversation .
Speaker 3Well , my publishing journey is an unusual one because I started out working in publishing and I still work in publishing . I started out as a bookseller and then a book publicist over 20 years ago . I worked at Macmillan and Penguin and then I switched to agenting . So I've been at a couple of other agencies before I started my own Courage Literary . So I have kind of had a 360-degree view of the industry . But I've always wanted to write review of the industry . But I've always wanted to write . I've always written and it's something that I love . But I had in my career I was always helping other people bring their stories to market or to the shelves , and so it's been an unusual journey of kind of writing on nights and weekends and now finally stepping into the author role after being the behind-the-scenes person for so long .
Speaker 2I love that For someone like myself who is fascinated by the idea of agenting . What got you into agenting and how did you start Courage Literary .
Speaker 3So it's kind of related to my career as a publicist , because I love talking about books . I love finding something , even if a book isn't my cup of tea , finding something I love about it and sharing it with people . And you know that feeling when you finish a good book you just want to talk about it with someone and see what someone else thought . So I love that aspect of publicity . But I wasn't in charge of my own projects . I had a little bit of leeway in getting to pick certain books I wanted to work on certain genres but it really wasn't up to me and by the time I got to work on books they were already edited , they were on their kind of last stop on the publishing journey . Edited they were on their kind of last stop on the publishing journey . So I really wanted to get closer to the process and select the projects and work with them from the beginning .
Speaker 3So that's why I explored becoming an agent and when I was in college I actually had an internship at the Wendy Weil Agency and she was a great lady , really smart , brought some wonderful , wonderful books to the world , and so I always had that in the back of my mind and so I took the leap and I agented at kind of a boutique size agency for about five , six years . Then I went to a larger agency for about the same amount of time and I realized , after having some successes and trying all the different environments , that I really wanted to go out on my own and bring the kind of books to the world that I think are interesting and smart and make the world a better place , whether it's fiction or nonfiction .
Speaker 2I love that , I love that . So on the agent side of things , what ?
Speaker 3are the biggest mistakes that you see authors making when you look in your slush pile . So I have been closed to queries for a while because I have my hands pretty full with my current client list . However , I'm still looking and evaluating things . You know I'll meet someone at a conference or a client will refer someone , but I've looked at probably a bazillion queries in my time and I will say that one of the one of the hardest . It's one of the hardest things in the world to boil down your beautiful 300 page book to a query letter . It is a very hard process so I have a lot of empathy and sympathy for authors going through that . It's not easy .
Speaker 3I think one common thing that I would see a lot is people just trying to sell it , sell it too hard and I come from a publicist background . I'm like you got to sell it , you got to put it in the best light , but saying it's going to be , you know , more popular than the Hunger Games or this or that , rather than focusing on what is the book about , what are its strengths , and , knowing the ballpark genre , I don't expect authors to be especially brand new authors , to be an expert on the publishing industry and every single genre and every single category and subcategory and every possible comp title . But have an idea of who your audience is , you know . If it's YA , say that it's YA . If it's more for adults , you know , getting those getting the ballpark genre down and then really sticking to like what's it about who ? You know ?
Speaker 3What readers do you think it will appeal to readers ? Do you think it will appeal to without kind of adding , oh , it will definitely do this in the market and I think the most successful authors I've seen have been able to infuse a little bit of their voice in that query letter . That's really hard because it's like a cover letter , it's like a business letter almost . But I've had clients who they write maybe they're a little bit funny or they've got a really warm voice and when those came through in the query I immediately thought I'm going to go right to the pages , I'm going to start reading this because I like the voice .
Speaker 2I love that . And when you get to those pages , what hooks you first ?
Speaker 3For me it's really voice and if I can become almost immediately immersed , there's a lot of things that can take you out of the story or really feel like I am reading a piece of writing . But when that filter falls away and you're just in it and you want to know what happens next , and you come to the end of those 10 pages or that 20 page sample and you know you got to read more . That's what does it for me and that's very subjective . You know there are so many books that might immerse someone else that I'm just not getting into or vice versa . But for me there's like an immediacy in the voice and I like things that are really intelligent , have something to say but are also entertaining and accessible . I want to get right in the story , but I want to be . I want to to have learned something or have have a new kind of outlook on something . By the time I'm done with the novel Love that , love that , love that .
Speaker 2Looking back , what do you think you did right that helped you break in to publishing ?
Speaker 3That's a good question . You know I worked really hard on this novel . Nothing Bad Happens . Here is my YA debut . It's the book of my heart , and I have been working on it in some form or another for maybe around 15 years and it started off as something very different , much lighter , for an even younger audience , and it has really evolved . But I worked really hard on it and it went through a lot of revisions and evolutions .
Speaker 3And so I think putting in the work , putting in the long hours of writing and revising , putting in the work , putting in the long hours of writing and revising , and then having worked in publishing , can be a pro and a con , because sometimes I feel like I know too much and it makes me overthink . On the other hand , it has helped me to realize I'm writing this thing that I love so much , but it may or may not resonate with other people , and so having to be a little bit delulue in saying hey , maybe someone else will like it , and putting myself out there because it would have been very easy for me to just keep doing what I'm doing and not take that creative risk or that creative leap and say , yes , I'm an agent , oh , but I also write , it feels a little bit vulnerable and so taking that leap where I had to really kind of honor how much work I've put into this and so I think that helped , I think , not letting the fear stop you from whether it's querying or reaching out to that agent or editor , you know putting in the time to write and revise . Yeah , I think that's it . Um , did I answer your question ?
Speaker 2you did , you did , and I always think to be a successful writer you have to be delusional . I say that to my friends all the time . So I love that you said , lulu , because a lot of times it's a marathon , not a sprint , and for some people it can take years to happen . So you have to have something in you that makes you keep going when the world is like nope , nope , nope . So you know you need that delusion , so that's a beautiful thing .
Speaker 3Yeah , I've seen , you know all sorts of publishing stories from working in publishing for so long , so I know it's not always one book that gets lucky . It's not all you know it's . There are so many factors outside of the writer's control . So I think it's important to focus on what you can control , because even if you work in the industry , you can't control . You know if it's going to get picked up , which publisher is going to buy it , who's going to love it , what's going to happen on publication , that sort of thing .
Speaker 2Do you think working as an agent , though , helps you as far as Like ? For example , a lot of writers struggle with coming up with like a marketable hook or an idea that will sell , but do you think being an agent gives you a little bit more insight when you're picking out what story ideas to pursue ?
Speaker 3I think it's helpful . And a hindrance Again . I see a lot of what people are responding to in the industry . I'm really aware of what's selling and what's working and what's not , but it can lead to overthinking , which is kind of the enemy of being creative and putting yourself out there . So I think it's been helpful , especially in my publicist and agent training .
Speaker 3Where you have to be , you know you're promoting others . You really want to get the word out about a book , and so I do my very best to spread the news about all the books I work on . It's very different when it's your own book . It feels more awkward and uncomfortable to do it for your own book , but I do think it helps because it helps . You see . Also there's so many books published . I'm sure you know the number of books published every year and so understanding that not every single book is for every person . So it's not necessarily about you and the worthiness of your soul or anything like that . But knowing that , I poured my heart and soul into this book and I hope that it finds readers that love it and resonate , and so it's a journey of finding those readers .
Speaker 2And I'm sure it will . I'm sure it will , let's see . You gave me so many different threads , directions to go , trying to pick where I want to go . Next you mentioned the market and what's selling . I'm curious what do you think is hot now ? What do you think is selling right now ? From your observations ?
Speaker 3Overall or in any particular area .
Speaker 2Primarily YA , but in other areas too , like are vampires still a thing or witches still booming .
Speaker 3I think . Well , romanticism and categories related romantasy are still going strong . It's tough out there for kid-led , it's tougher for YA and middle grade right now , which is unfortunate , but I think that there's always a hunger and an interest for stories where there are magical
Insights on Writing, Publishing, and Marketing
Speaker 3creatures or some aspect of reality that's a little different , a little special . And even though we've had so many different trends with different names you know , we used to call things paranormal , we used to call things supernatural there's the romantic and fantasy trend and I think there's always a hunger for what if the world were different ? Or what if I had some power or some other ability ? So I think there's always going to be an . There's a kind of magical , mythical thread that some readers pick up more on and some readers pick up less on . But it's there and I am really interested in that line of well , what is real , what is imagined , what are the possibilities in our world , and I just think that's really fun to explore . And then I think YA mysteries and thrillers readers are gobbling them up .
Speaker 3So I think we're going to see some more of that as well .
Speaker 2Love that . How about in the adult market ?
Speaker 3Adult is interesting . So I do a mix of fiction and nonfiction and we're seeing nonfiction cool off just a tiny bit and fiction is doing really , really well . We're seeing some similar patterns . You know romanticism going strong , but we're really like what I'm seeing . Work are stories that are immersive , transportive , have an element of escapism , so the reader can feel like they're taken somewhere else in their mind , and I think we're going to see more of that .
Speaker 2I love that . Tell me the story behind the story . How did your current novel come to be ? Nothing bad happens here .
Speaker 3How did that ?
Speaker 3come to be will come to be . Nothing bad happens here . How did that come to be ? Well , I have always wanted to set a book on Nantucket . Nantucket is this tiny island off the coast of Cape Cod . It's 30 miles out to sea . It's very picturesque and foggy and mysterious and it's got beautiful beaches and I grew up going there every summer and so I spent a lot of time as a kid I was an only child reading a lot of books , spending time by myself , kind of wishing something exciting would happen to me , like in the books I was reading . So that feeling kind of percolated over the years , along with my interest in stories about mermaids and selkies and anything kind of nautical and mythological .
Speaker 3And I wanted to blend that with the story of a very real teenage girl who is she's having some issues . She's a grieving teen . She's kind of drifting along through her grief , and she gets this opportunity to go to Nantucket for a summer where everything in her life changes . She meets three beautiful and mysterious girls who kind of sweep her up into their world . So she's having a lot of fun with them . She's having they're doing lots of joyful chaos . They're experiencing a lot of joyful chaos as they go out together and have fun on the island , but meanwhile some very bad things are happening on this beautiful island and danger is kind of lurking beneath the pastel . You know , beautiful window box , island atmosphere . And so I knew I always wanted to write a story about a girl in Nantucket , possibly with some sea creatures , with some mysteries involved , and it grew and evolved over the years to be nothing bad happens here .
Speaker 2I love that . What makes a good thriller ?
Speaker 3seat and I love those . I love the pulse pounding feeling you got to turn the pages . But I also love psychological thrillers where there's something going on and the protagonist has to figure it out and things might not be quite as high octane or pulse pounding , but there's something unsettling or weird going on and the protagonist I like it when it's a woman or weird going on and the protagonist I like it when it's a woman or a young woman is trying to figure it out , trying to figure out what's really going on , and so I like it when there is that atmospheric build of certain things seem a little weird or not right , but the character may be also dealing with her own issues , whether it's a mental health issue or a friendship issue or some other aspect of her life is in disarray Meanwhile . All these things are going on . I just love that .
Speaker 2I love that too . So which do you think Nothing Bad Happens here moves toward ? Is it more of a psychological thriller ? Because that's what I was getting from your description earlier .
Speaker 3Yes , yes , I think that Nothing Bad Happens . Here is more of a psychological thriller where you're going with the main character from one state of understanding the world to another state and thrilling things happen , dangerous and mysterious things happen . There is a bit of an investigation that she is undergoing , but it's more about her journey as a character , her psychological journey going from a place of being adrift in grief to being a little more powerful and having a little more agency in her life , making some very difficult decisions .
Speaker 2And is there a killer involved ? A monster ? Tease me a little more .
Speaker 3There is a killer . So the book starts . The book starts with a scene where a teenage girl dies or is killed and then we are with the main character . As she arrives on the island , she is going to discover a girl washed up on the beach . And that's what kicks off all of her suspicions and sort of investigations . And finding a dead girl on the beach is very traumatic and it opens up a lot of wounds for my main character , lucia , from her past . So while she's kind of grappling with oh my gosh , I've discovered this body .
Speaker 3Who is this girl ? What's going on on this beautiful island where a girl my age could wash up dead ? She's also kind of poking and exploring some of these old wounds in her past . So there is something going on on the island , but we don't know what . And she is trying to figure it out because she feels that the police aren't really paying attention to this girl . Nobody really seems to care . There's a flurry of media attention and then it dies out because everyone wants to keep the nice facade of we're in this beautiful you know beautiful island where everything is perfect and everyone is wealthy and happy , and that's not really going with the narrative of that . But she can't let it go . She wants to know who is this girl and what happened to her .
Speaker 2You had me at washed up on the shore . That is a great hook for the start of a novel . That's awesome . Thank you , kudos to you for that . That was awesome . You also did , or are working on , murder by Cheesecake , yes , which is more of a cozy mystery . How did that project come together ?
The Unusual Publishing Journey
Speaker 3So Murder by Cheesecake is an official Golden Girls cozy mystery with our beloved characters from the Golden Girls and the publisher who works with the company that owns the rights to the Golden Girls . They were looking for somebody who could do this project and I knew the editor for a long time . We've worked together over the years , had a good friendship for a long time . We've worked together over the years , had a good friendship , and I have a goofy sense of humor and I love the Golden Girls . I mean , who doesn't ? But I really love the Golden Girls .
Speaker 3So this was another one of those put myself out there moments where I said , may I try out for this , may I audition for this ? And I did . I wrote . I can't remember how long my sample was , but I wrote sample pages . They loved them . They wanted to see a revision . I worked on that and I got the gig and so it has been . That's , you know , kind of the opposite story of the usual publishing journey . Kind of the opposite story of the usual publishing journey because it's the Golden Girls . But I came up with the plot and the ins and outs of everything . You know . They had a rough idea of what they wanted to see and I needed to be very true to the characters and the setting and I have to tell you it was so fun to spend time with these four ladies and be in , like the eighties and nineties Miami Florida setting . Um , that was so . That was a dream come true .
Speaker 2Now , was um that your first IP project , or had you written IP before ?
Speaker 3Yes , I had done some like ghostwriting and book doctoring in the past . This is my first official like IP project adult and adult novel .
Speaker 2Let's see , that sounds like a dream , though . I love the Golden Girls too , and Sophia's a hoot , so I bet that was really fun .
Speaker 3Which one ? Which one do you relate to ?
Speaker 2too . Sophia is my favorite . If I had to compare personalities , I'd say I'm a Dorothy most days , but I aspire to be a Sophia because I love her little snappy comebacks .
Speaker 3Yeah , so I always thought of myself as a Rose , but I feel like I've got a lot of Dorothy in me now . But Sophia has been growing on me . I used to think when I was younger like when I was a little kid watching the show I used to think she was so mean , and now I just I agree with her .
Speaker 2She's definitely the most honest of the characters . I'll give her that .
Speaker 3Yeah , I mean , she's really got the comebacks , the quippy remarks .
Speaker 2What does your writing process look like ? Do you have any routines or anything Like ? What does a writing day look like for you ?
Speaker 3So because I work as an agent which takes up a lot of my creative and strategic brain , I'm pretty much doing that full time during the week , and so my writing is mostly on the weekends . I'll try to have a good cup of coffee and just get as many words on the page as I can . I tend to be a messier first draft writer and then work to revise it and refine it , so my process is mostly like a weekend weekend sprint . I did finally , for my birthday last year , get a free write which is kind of like a typewriter , and I find that really useful for getting your words and thoughts out without too much over editing at the time , and then I put it into a Word document and refine and edit as I go .
Speaker 2I love that . Let's see how do you balance it all with agenting an agency and your writing career . That's got to be hard it's a lot of work .
Speaker 3It's a lot of work and , um , yeah , it's a lot of work . I try to compartmentalize so that when I'm when I'm agenting during the week , I'm really just agenting , I'm focused on my clients , my head is in their work , and it's very , very hard . But on the weekend I try to compartmentalize the other way and it's hard because in publishing you are reading and editing a lot on nights and weekends and it is kind of an all consuming job . So it is kind of hard to switch over . But that's kind of how I do it is . I try to reserve my writing time for for the weekends . But it's funny because those worlds are starting to intersect . Clients of mine are , you know , they're going to be reading the books and they've all been very supportive , which is wonderful . But it's also nerve wracking because I admire my clients writing so much . They're master plotters , they're master writers . What are they going to think of my book ?
Speaker 2I'm sure they'll love it . How do you approach building suspense when you're writing a thriller ?
Speaker 3In . Nothing Bad Happens here . I build suspense in a couple of ways . One is through atmosphere . So I find Nantucket to be full of atmosphere . When it's sunny it's really beautiful and cute and picturesque . But when the fog comes down and it's misty it's so much more mysterious and it's very historical . All the houses are gray shingle , there are no neon lights , there are not even traffic lights on the island , just stop signs . So it's easy to kind of imagine yourself in another world or in any point in time . So part of it was playing with the atmosphere . When is it more ominous ? And also , when is the kind of picture perfect vacation town facade also kind of ominous ? So part of it is that and then part of it is the interaction between characters . How are the characters acting ? Are they acting off ? Is something up ? Who's hiding something ? What cues is the protagonist picking up on or not picking up on ? But maybe the reader is seeing . So I like sprinkling those things in as well .
Speaker 2I love that when you're reading a thriller , what makes it unforgettable to you ?
Speaker 3I love twists . I love twists and trying to guess who the person is and being wrong at the end , and I love books that leave something up to the interpretation of the reader . So an example of a great twist is obviously Gone Girl . There's a big twist right in the middle . Our first third of the book that you know , the first time I read it made me gasp . I might have screamed even out loud . So I love a twist like that . But then there are books where they leave you questioning things or wondering things , and this isn't necessarily a thriller , but Bunny by Mona Awad has a lot of weird things going on and it really makes you think about it and want to talk to other people and see what they think of the ending , and so I like both of those things for different types of books .
Speaker 2What makes a good cozy mystery ?
Speaker 3A cozy mystery is also all about atmosphere , but in a different way . It's about the comfy , cozy vibes , the even though there's a dead body and an investigation , you know a murder has occurred or a death has occurred . You're really bonding with the characters and the environment . So , whatever the setting is , whatever the time period or the theme is , you're getting immersed in it . It's a comfy world that you would love to go to with a good book and a cup of tea that you'd like to hang out in . Hopefully , you know when there aren't any murders going on out in .
Speaker 2Hopefully you know , when there aren't any murders going on . What are the ?
Speaker 3essential elements of a good first page For me . I really like it to be vivid . I want to be immersed , and that means well-chosen , vivid details to get me right in the story . And that doesn't mean you know long passages of description where nothing happens , but a few well-chosen details where I can feel and see and hear where I am with the characters in their story , and a strong voice always helps .
Speaker 2How do you avoid the saggy middle ?
Speaker 3That's really hard . That's really hard , honestly . I think that's where having other readers can help , whether you have an agent or an editor , beta readers you know critique partners . Sometimes it's really helpful to have someone else tell you can this happen sooner , does this need to happen ? And in your mind it needed to happen , but does it really need to happen or does it need to happen for 50 pages ? Does it really need to happen or does it need to happen for 50 pages ? So I think getting outside reads can really help with that and being really honest with yourself about what's moving the story forward and what story are you actually writing .
Speaker 2And how do you tie it all up at the end and make a satisfying ending for your readers ?
Speaker 3It's challenging . I think a lot of writers know where they're going . You know there's plotters and pantsers , and some people really know where they're going at the end and some people have to figure it out as they go . And I find that , even if you're figuring it out as you go , the roots of that ending were there all along or were building subconsciously . So I think it's about giving the reader some answers , but also allowing some room for their imagination and intelligence to decide for themselves if they feel it is satisfying or interesting . I like to know things , but I also love when things are up for interpretation , and I'm one of those people that when I finish the book , I want to talk to the author and say , okay , but what really happened at this part ? Or what's going to happen the next day ? So yeah , so I think it's about giving the reader answers but allowing them to form some of their own decisions as well .
Speaker 2I love that . Do you have any advice on crafting a good villain or antagonist ? Do you have any ?
Speaker 3advice on crafting a good villain or antagonist . So I think some of the most interesting villains are the ones that hide in plain sight , and I think that's even creepier if someone can seem so lovely and they've got another agenda . So I think that seeing your villains as fully human understanding , maybe why they are that way , that doesn't excuse their villainous deeds . But you're kind of building up a psychological profile of maybe why they acted the way they did . Profile of maybe why they acted the way they did . And I always love it when I don't when I don't see them coming .
Speaker 2Oh , love all that . What makes good character for protagonists ?
Speaker 3I think that writers put so much thought and care into their characters . You know there are writers that know exactly what their character would eat for breakfast on a Thursday .
Speaker 3know there are writers that know exactly what their character would eat for breakfast on a Thursday , and I think , um , really understanding a character's motivation and feelings , almost like an actor stepping into a role um is a real is really valuable .
Speaker 3And I also feel like when you read a book and you feel like you're friends with the characters or you wish you were um , it doesn't have to be like this for every book , but you can kind of tell how much the author cared about the characters , even if they put them through horrible things . Um , you feel a closeness to the character , and whether that's because they've built , they've done a lot of work trying to figure out every aspect of the character , or they're just written so true to what their thoughts and actions would be and their dialogue , I think I can feel an author's closeness to a character , or at least that's the effect of a really well-written character . And I always love it too when you you can get mad at a character or you want to be friends with a character . You wish you could talk to them and say please don't , please don't walk down that path , please don't go through that door .
Speaker 2I love that . How do you yourself , when you're writing , know when your story's done ?
Speaker 3That's really hard , I think , when you feel it's as close to what you have envisioned as possible . Nothing is ever going to be perfect and you could edit and tinker and revise forever . You really really could . And so I think , when it's as close to what your vision is as possible and when your editor tells you it's ready , you have to step away . But it's hard , you could tinker forever , and so I think it's a feeling of it's as close as I can get it , it's as close to perfect , and sometimes that comes with putting it down for a little while . Maybe you step away from it for a week or so and you realize that you have done what you're trying to do .
Speaker 2I interviewed an author years ago who basically described writing a book as having a bunch of friends come over talking about her characters . And then I was like , well , how do you know when it's over ? She's like they leave .
Speaker 3My characters have not left me . I still feel like maybe for for nothing bad happens here . I feel like those characters are still out there , living their lives , making choices , good or bad . You know , maybe I'd run into them someday in Nantucket and then with the Golden Girls , they're very much alive in my head . I think if you're a fan , like I am , you can hear certain lines in your head for any of the characters . You can hear that theme song and it fills you with good vibes . So for me , I feel very much that we are in a golden girls world . I love that .
Speaker 2So I'm going to have you slide your agent hat on just for a second again . So you're not you , but you're another author and you just finished this masterpiece . We discussed how to craft and now you're sending a query letter . What are some tips for making sure that that query letter turns out good and gets attention ?
Speaker 3OK , well , first of all , I would back up a little bit and I would put the manuscript down for a week and celebrate finishing something , finishing a book-length manuscript , which is not an easy task . Give yourself a mental break from it and either have someone else read it or look at it again and make sure it's revised and polished before you start querying . Then , on the querying journey , I would probably let myself write several bad and messy query letters that I would then refine into an ideal query letter , which would it doesn't have to be overly personal I would research the agents and I would give a little almost log line of the book it's this meets , that set in blank , or it's this genre with this sort of twist or this aspect to it . I would spend a short amount of time explaining the plot and a short bio . If you don't have a ton of accolades already , just say who you are and where you live , and if you have a dog or a cat . You don't have to worry about having a lot of writing credits or awards or a certain type of education .
Speaker 3The clients that I sell have every type of experience , and so , for the query letter , there are so many good examples online and resources online to get for your query . So I would make sure that it reads clearly and professionally and I would do kind of a pass to see if there's any way I can infuse my voice into it a bit more , because if it comes off reading really stiff , you know it's a business document but you want it to sound . If you're funny , a little funny . If you're serious , a little serious . Infuse it with some voice and I would say it is helpful when a querying author has some good comps in their query letter . Comps are really hard and I do not expect a brand new writer to know every single book that's ever been published or even every book in their genre .
Speaker 3But if you're picking things that this meets that or for readers of this and that , that kind of give you a general gist of who the readership is , that's really helpful because it shows me what you think the book is , who the book is for , and it shows that you're reading in your genre and you're participating in the world of books and your comp isn't just one book you read in high school , um , but you're really reading things that are current and coming out and I think that just that just reflects well too , um , trying to think I think that's it , oh , and then I would , yeah , I would send it off , I would .
Speaker 3I would send it off with you . Know , you have to be a little delulue and confident and just know that if the book doesn't resonate with any particular agent , that's because of where they are in their life or their business or their personal taste . It's not a reflection on you or necessarily the quality of your work . So you have to really keep up this like positive attitude , to keep going , even if you do start to get some passes or crickets for a while .
Speaker 2And once they have sent out their 131st query and they get the one yes , that's needed because you only need the one . So once they get that one yes , and they have the phone call , what is the agent looking for in the call ?
Speaker 3As an agent , I'm mostly there to hear from the author . I want to be there to answer their questions about me or the agency or about the publishing process . I see it as an opportunity to really open up , because I think that publishing can seem very opaque when you're not in it . So for me I see it as an opportunity to answer questions and talk about publishing and their work in particular . I'm not really auditioning the client or potential client . I do want to get a sense of if our communication styles are compatible and if I had any editorial thoughts on the book , are they open to it ? Is it against their vision ? Does it go with their vision ? Do I think you know we'd work well together ? But really it's an opportunity to get to know each other and , you know , kind of fling open the gates to the publishing world .
Speaker 2And as somebody who knows the business on the other side , if there's somebody who's on the other end of that phone what should they be wanting to know from the agent ? What kind of questions should they ask ?
Speaker 3I think my first question to an agent would be you know what about my story resonated with you ? What did you like ? So you kind of get a sense of what they're connecting with and how they see it . Is there anything you think could be done better or differently ? I think that's a really good question because it helps the author see do we have similar visions ? Does this agent get what I'm trying to do and like it , or do they want to make it something that is not or that I don't want it to be ? So I think that's really helpful . And then I think asking them about their process , how it all works from beginning to end , I think is really helpful . Even if you're excited and you might not retain all that information immediately . I think getting a sense of how the process works with that agent and that agency is really helpful .
Speaker 2I love that . Okay , so now your book is finished , you're ready to send your baby into the world and , as someone who's been a publicist yourself , what are your plans on marketing and stuff like that for your projects ?
Speaker 3So for both of my books . I am lucky to have a traditional publisher with publicity and marketing departments , and I'm very grateful for that , because I worked as a publicist and I think publicists are some of the hardest working people in publishing , and the business has changed a lot . You know it's harder to get coverage in places like newspapers , that you know we don't have as much book coverage as we used to have . However , there are a lot of opportunities online , and so what I'm trying to do is get the word out as best I can through every medium . I still would love there to be some coverage in traditional media , but I also know that's really hard these days .
Speaker 3I want to let everyone that I'm connected with know about the books so that they know when it's coming out , what it's about , where they can buy it , and a lot of that is through social media and newsletters and also doing events . You know , bookstore events can be hit or miss depending on the type of audience you're going to bring in , what the weather is outside that day . But I think having some events where people can gather and you can talk about the book
Transitioning from Publicist to Agent
Speaker 3in person is really wonderful , and I am for Nothing Bad Happ happens here . For example , my first event is going to be at a local bookstore and I'm trying to make it like a Nantucket beach party , so there will be a book signing and a reading , but I'm going to have , you know , beach party beverages and snacks and a playlist and things like that to make it a little more fun .
Speaker 2I love that . That's really cute . Were there any DIY tips you could throw out for our authors who are trying to support their publicists ?
Speaker 3Yeah , there is a lot you can do as an author . So I would think about every single connection you have , whether it's personal , professional or some sort of organization in your community , and I would really think about who all those people are and how you reach them . Maybe it's a personal email , maybe it's through social media , making sure you give any and all information . You talk it over with your publicist . So if you happen to know someone in the media or someone who has a big social media following , you're sharing that . But you're also working within your community . If you've got a local bookstore and library , make sure you're an active participant . Your community , if you've got a local bookstore and library , make sure you're an active participant . You go to those events , you shop there , introduce yourself to the bookseller or librarian , maybe give them some materials on your book . I think it's really helpful when you have something you can hand to them and you're not just talking , you're not just saying I have a book and it's really being published , please support me , but you can hand them something so they can look at it , show it to their supervisor , maybe order the book later after you've left the building , that sort of thing .
Speaker 3And I would say , also try to do something that's authentic to you , because there's so many ways to market a book and there's a lot of noise out there . So for my cover reveal , for Nothing Bad Happens here . So my book has a broken seashell on the cover . It's like a cracked seashell and as soon as I saw that , I had this idea for a cover reveal where I got a big seashell just like on my cover and I smashed it with a hammer and that was just . You know , that was kind of a silly fun idea that I had . That was a little out there , but people really liked it when I posted a video of me doing that on social media . So trying to do things outside the box that are authentic to you .
Speaker 3Let me think what else I think also understanding who your audience is . So if you're writing kidlit , can you speak to schools ? Can you reach any teachers or librarians or educators or parents with your book ? If you're writing adult literary fiction , that's a completely different audience . So knowing who your audience is , where they congregate online and IRL , and meeting them there and I live in Pittsburgh , which has a really robust literary community and actually Litzburgcom celebrates the literary history of Pittsburgh Me and my husband , nick Courage , manage it , and it's really great to see other authors showing up at other authors' events and supporting each other , and we think that's a great way also to build a community and get the word out .
Speaker 2I love that and librarians also like snacks . I work at a library and you know .
Speaker 3Okay , so what kind of snacks , what kind of ?
Speaker 2snacks . Somebody came in one time and it was really cute because she had a card for her book and it had the ISBN number and all that stuff on it and it had the cover on the card . And then she had these like Rice Krispie treats on these lollipop sticks and it was attached to the lollipop and I was like that's cute and clever and memorable . We'll remember you know that book . Yeah , I love that . Yeah , that was clever . I liked that too and I ate like several . Shame to say how many lollipops I took off of that plate , but anyway , I'm rambling . Um , you've given us some great tips from like querying Um , is there any one tool or resource or website or anything that you found the most helpful for you through any of this process whether it was the creation process or the promoting your book process that you'd want to recommend to aspiring authors ?
Speaker 3There are so many I don't know if I can pick one . You can say them all . Well , okay . So I will just say for authors in general , whether you're querying or you're just trying to talk about your book more once it's published , I think it's really really helpful just to see how other books are being talked about . So , whether you're looking at the description online or you're browsing in a bookstore or library , I think it's really helpful to see the kind of language that they're using to describe , you know , books like yours . How long is the description ? You know , what are people resonating with and talking about ? I just think .
Speaker 3I just think that's that's really helpful , because it is hard to to . You know , write the book of your heart and then say , oh my gosh , how am I going to boil this down ? Write the book of your heart and then say , oh my gosh , how am I going to boil this down ? What's my elevator pitch ? What is my short description ?
Speaker 3So I think kind of looking at what other people have done and adapting it for yourself is really helpful .
Speaker 3I know I used to do some work with them and I know a lot of authors have found help through Manuscript Academy , where you can get a critique either on your query or on pages , and I think that can be really , really helpful .
Speaker 3And also I just I find there are certain books that I just love Stephen King's On Writing . I have a very dog-eared copy , and it's not necessarily just for the tips . It's more about recognizing that it is hard to write a book and that part of it is mental and emotional , and pushing through to finish it , pushing through to share it with other people , having the courage to go out there and try to get published , and remembering that it's not easy for anyone . It's really something to be , it's an accomplishment to be celebrated , whether you've just finished a manuscript or wherever you are in the publishing journey . So I think it's really important to recognize it , because I've worked on a lot of books , I've worked in publishing for a long time and now I really know how much work it is for an author not just to write the book but to revise , to promote , to jump through all the hoops to get to that publication day . I know it in my bones and I just have so much respect for anyone who attempts to do that .
Speaker 2Are you going to have a party ?
Speaker 3I am . So I'm going to have the Nantucket Beach Party as a launch party in March and then , when Murder by Cheesecake comes out in April , I'm going to have a party with cheesecake at another bookstore to celebrate it . And if people want to dress up like the Golden Girls , that's fine with me .
Speaker 2That is really cute . I love that Sounds fun and exciting . That's really cute . I love that Sounds fun and exciting . Best piece of writing advice you ever had . You ever heard .
Speaker 3Best piece of writing advice . Well , I don't know who originally said it , but I have seen the phrase . It has to exist before it is good , and so you have to have something on the page . You have to have a manuscript that you can improve and revise . So if you're stopping yourself from writing because it might not be perfect when it comes out , then you won't have a book . So I think creating something even if it's messy , even if it's hard , it takes you a really long time I think is really , really worth it . You can always make it better . You can always make it better . You can always change it . You can always decide you want to write a different idea .
Speaker 2But start , something has to exist first love it , love it , love it , love it . How have you felt about the debut process as a whole so far ? Any surprises or challenges that you ran into ?
Speaker 3You know , I know how hard it is to get a book published . So I feel very lucky . Even with all the hard work that I put in , I still know that . You know luck plays a big role , so I feel really lucky . It's also really scary . I thought that , because I've been in the industry and I'm an agent , that I would very quickly be able to see , um , for example , nothing bad happens here as a book , as a product on the shelf me , and that has been a real journey for me to realize I'm putting a piece of my heart out there . So that's just been scary but exciting . And , yeah , I just feel like , as the author , you have to be a really strong advocate for your book and for yourself , while also understanding it's a group effort . You've got people in your publisher , people in your family . You know you don't do this in a vacuum , and so I just feel like I'm really grateful for the process .
Speaker 2Have you anxiety spiraled ? No , because my book Heart's Gambit comes out in winter of 2026 . Oh , congrats , thank you . And you would think like when it's a lifelong goal and you finally reach it , you would think it would be just joy . But I keep finding myself like anxiety spiraling and then getting into these like swirls of imposter syndrome and just driving myself nuts , like when they asked me for blurbs . I'm like my agent probably thought I was insane because she asked me for blurbs and I gave her this super long list because my anxiety was like well , nobody will like it , you won't be good enough , you'll have to go through all these people . And then I was like realizing how crazy I probably looked . So I wrote her back and I apologized . I'm like you know you don't have to do that many . Sorry , I was having a moment . Have you had any of those moments , or is that just a me ?
Speaker 3thing . I think everybody has those moments . So , as an agent , I'm often talking people down from those moments . I'm giving them pep talks , I'm reminding them how excellent their work is , I'm reminding them of all the hard work and how much I , you know even if it's only me , I'm like the editor who has read it I'm reminding them of that . So I'm usually on the other side of that conversation . I think every author struggles with anxiety and nerves and worries about how the book will be received , and I'm like every author in that I have shared those feelings . I have tried to give myself the agent pep talk . It doesn't work . It doesn't work on yourself . You know it's helpful .
Speaker 3My husband , nick Courage , is also an author and I'm very lucky to have him in my life building me up , supporting me , pulling me back from the brink . But it's scary . I mean , when I sent my book out for blurbs you know nobody has to blurb , everybody's busy . Even if they said yes , they'll take a look , that doesn't mean they're actually going to do it . So I think for me things started to feel real is when I started getting blurbs and you think , okay , it's not just me and my husband and my editor who like this book . But congrats to you and I would just say remember all the hard work you put in and it's very easy , you know , to not do that , to sit back and not publish a book and not put yourself out there . And you did the hard thing already . Yeah , but it's , it's hard . So we went what month is it coming up ? Do you know yet ?
Speaker 2You said I don't know the month yet , I just don't winter 2026. , but , like I said , it's . And when you , you care , when you love your craft , you care what people think . So the idea of , like the people you admire , reading your work is like terrifying . I think that's why I started the spiral , because it's like you know what I mean and you know .
Speaker 3But JD , what if they like it ? That's true , it's true , but if they really then that's true .
Speaker 2I need to look at the positives , because I worked hard on it , I like it , I think it's really good and my agent was excited about it . So I guess I should try to look at the positives and my friends . The pep talk my friends are giving me is like somebody bought this , so that means they saw a value in it . So you know , calm yourself .
Speaker 3What's the title of it ? Again , heart's Gambit , heart's Gambit , oh , that's a good title . Yeah , you have to remind yourself . You're not the only easier to say oh , I have this external praise rather than just telling , rather than just telling yourself , but it's totally normal . It means you're a real liar .
Speaker 2You know I have greatly enjoyed chatting with you . If your words are as lovely as your personality , I am sure you will top all the charts , because you just have a very warm spirit .
Speaker 3Thank you . Oh my gosh . Well , this is the first interview I've done . I'm very nervous , and so thank you for saying that .
Speaker 2Is there anything you wanted to add that I didn't cover , or anything you wanted to promote or mention One ?
Speaker 3thing .
Speaker 3I just wanted to promote , or mention One thing I just wanted to add a little bit , for Nothing Bad Happens here , my YA debut . I just wanted to mention some of my literary influences because you know , I grew up as a reader and I always wanted to , you know , write something mysterious by the sea , and I think that the books I read as a kid and as a teenager and as an adult , they all kind of have influenced me in different ways . So , whether it's like the Selkie myth or the original , like Hans Christian Anderson , the Little Mermaid , but taking that and making it a little bit more modern and a little darker , but mixed with reading books by Joan Aiken and then some of the really great spooky kids authors like RL Stine and Lois Duncan I think those really affected me too . And then also Nantucket has a really rich literary tradition . There's a lot of authors either from there or who are right about it , and so I just wanted to mention some of the other authors that I think really inspired me , along with the setting of Nantucket Love that ?
Speaker 2Where can people connect with you ?
Speaker 3So I my website is rachelxfromcouragecom . I have lots of fun stuff up there . I have a newsletter which is rachelextromecourage at Substack . I'm on Instagram as rachelextromecourage . Those are the places that I am most active , I would say website , newsletter and Instagram . One thing I wanted to mention is I had mentioned that I was closed to queries , but I'm not always going to be closed to queries to say and then if people are interested in like querying me , they can you know , go to my website .
Speaker 2My agency website is couragecom and I'll say that . I'll just say that you will be opening up in the coming months , but I won't give an exact date . That way they know that the door is not forever closed . How's that ?
Speaker 3Yeah , Okay , and when you said where to find me , I gave you all the author stuff , but the agent stuff is . Courageliterarycom is a good place to start for the authors who are more interested in the agenting side of things than you know the author side of my life .
Speaker 2Yeah , love it , love it . You're a woman of many skills . I am excited to see what's coming , and they sent me a review copy of the book , so I can't wait to read it too . Love your cover , by the way .
Speaker 3Oh good , oh , thank you , and if you need anything else sent to you , let me know .
Speaker 2Thank you so much . Enjoy the rest of your day and have a healthy , happy , joyous pregnancy . I'll keep you guys in my prayers and well wishes and all that good stuff , thank you so much , thank you , I'm trying .
Speaker 3I'm so tired but I'm trying . Well , thank you so much . Have a great rest of your day , and I really appreciate you doing this .
Speaker 2Thank you , I appreciate you too and I hate to be the bearer of bad news , but , honey , you don't know tired yet . Till when that baby comes , I hope you have relatives that'll be there to help you , because you're going to be tired . My friend , I had twins and with two of them waking up , you would think they'd wake up at the same time , but no , but with two of them waking up all night I was so delirious with sleep . I come up one morning well , one night and I'm feeding the baby , and then I go make a bottle , feed the other baby , and then I look across the room like why are you still crying ? And then I realized I fed the same baby twice . That's how tired I was . The other baby was across the room starving .
Speaker 3I'm so tired , delirious . I'm so glad we're talking . I may be asking you some non-book related questions down the line . Yeah , that's fine too .
Speaker 1Have a great day , sweetie . Be safe you too . That wraps up today's Craft Chat Chronicles with JD Mayer . Thanks for joining us . If you liked the episode , please comment , subscribe and share . For show notes , writing , writing workshops and tips , head to jdmayorcom . That's jdmayorcom . While you're there , join jd's mailing list for updates , giveaways and more .