Craft Chat Chronicles
Craft Chat Chronicles
Season 3 Episode 11: Alan Gratz Reveals the Secrets Behind His NYT Bestseller Success – and How You Can Achieve It Too
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
New York Times bestselling author Alan Gratz takes us on a captivating journey from the struggles of an unagented writer to achieving literary success. Discover the vital lessons Alan learned while navigating the traditional publishing industry, including the pivotal role of attending conferences and joining organizations like SCBWI. Gain insights into the challenges and triumphs of writing query letters that capture attention, as well as the persistence required to overcome rejections. Alan opens up about his partnership with his agent, Holly Root, and their collaborative efforts in shaping his career.
Listeners are treated to a deep dive into the art of revision, a process Alan mastered through a transformative talk by Linda Sue Park. Offering a glimpse into the rise of indie and self-publishing, Alan shares his strategies for choosing projects that fit his brand while embracing unconventional side ventures. Explore how Alan and Holly navigate the dynamics of publisher contracts, emphasizing the necessity of continuous work production and adaptability in the ever-evolving publishing landscape.
The episode also explores the intricacies of crafting thrillers for young readers, emphasizing the significance of a fast-paced narrative and the importance of a gripping opening. Alan's passion for storytelling shines as he discusses story structure and character development, drawing inspiration from classics like "The Wizard of Oz" and "The Hobbit." Whether you're an aspiring author or an avid reader, this episode offers a treasure trove of insights on building a sustainable writing career and delivering stories that captivate audiences.
https://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener-affiliate.html?fpr=craftchat
🎙️ Craft Chat Chronicles with J.D. Myall
Candid conversations on writing, publishing, and creative life — featuring bestselling authors, MFA students, and writers at every stage of the journey.
About J.D. Myall
J.D. Myall is the co-chair of Drexel University’s MFA Alumni Association and a publishing and library professional. She is the creator and host of Craft Chat Chronicles, where she interviews authors, agents, and industry insiders about the art and business of writing.
Her work has appeared in Ms. Magazine, Writer’s Digest, and HuffPost. Her debut novel, Heart’s Gambit, releases with Wednesday Books/Macmillan in February 2026.
When she’s not conjuring magic, murder, and mayhem on the page, J.D. mentors emerging writers through workshops and alumni programs, fostering community among aspiring and published authors alike.
💜 Connect with J.D. Myall
📸 Instagram
🌐 Website & Media Kit
💌 Newsletter
🔗 Linktree
Watch episodes on YouTube as well.
💜 Level up your writing process with Scrivener — the ...
Craft Chat Chronicles
Speaker 1Welcome to Craft Chat Chronicles , the go-to podcast for tips on crafting best-selling fiction . Here at Craft Chat Chronicles , we bring you expert interviews , insights and tips on writing , publishing and marketing . Join the conversation and embark on a new chapter in your writing journey . For workshops , show notes and more information , visit jdmyallcom . That's jdmyallcom .
Speaker 2In season three , episode 11 of Craft Chat Chronicles , we talk to New York Times bestselling author Alan Grant . Alan has given us titles like Refugee and Resist . He's written tons of books for Scholastic and other publishers and he's generous with his knowledge on writing craft and what it takes to hook readers from the start and keep them all the way through Season three , episode 11 of Craft Chat Chronicles . Let's get chatty . So tell me about your publishing journey . How did you find your agent ?
Speaker 3So I began . My first book came out in 2006 , but I sold it in 2003 , the end of 2002 , beginning of 2003, . And I was unagented . This was back in the era when you could send stuff in through the slush pile . Maybe you still can , but I know that things have changed a lot . I was sending novels out into editorial slush piles and the first book I sold was the third book that I had written and submitted to publishers . The first two never got published . The third book became my first published book . That book was Samurai Shortstop and it was still .
Speaker 3I think 15 different publishers said no before the 16th said yes , said yes , and then , once I got that offer , I had a lot of friends that I had made who were published authors by going to conferences and conventions and things , and they said , okay , now go get an agent . And so I basically cold called a few agents and said I have a book that I've got an offer from Dial , from an imprint at Penguin , and would you represent me ? And that's how I found my very first agent . It's not the way you do things . It's not the way I think you're supposed to do things . It's certainly not the way I recommend people do things now , but it was a little bit of a different time and so I've been with two or three different agents since then and so the person that I'm with now was not that original person who picked me up . I'm now with Holly Root of Root Literary and she's terrific and love her . But that's how I got started was sending things into editors and getting lots and lots of rejections .
Speaker 3This was , yeah , I guess the Harry Potter era had begun in kidlit , but it hadn't really taken hold like that era of fantasy . Kidlit fantasy really saw the explosion in the number of agents who were willing to take on Kidlet and at the time when I was first submitting my books , there were maybe six people who admitted in the Writer's Digest big fat book that you used to get , and they would say that I also do children's books . Just big fat book that you used to get and they would say that I also do children's books . So once I had exhausted like all six of those , I was submitting to editors . And now of course it's a whole different landscape . There are dozens and dozens of terrific agents who are handling kid lit and many of whom that's all they do . So it's just a different landscape . Now I feel like an old man of kidlit publishing 20 books on .
Speaker 2That's a beautiful thing . How long have you been with Holly Root ?
Speaker 3She and I have been working together since when was that ? Maybe 2015 or 2016 , somewhere in there Ban this Book , which we're going to talk about , and Book Banning was one of my first book deals I did with her through her , and I think that book came out in 2017 .
Speaker 2Looking back , what do you think you did right that helped you become the published author that you are today ?
Speaker 3I went to a lot of conferences and read a lot of books about how to be professional and you know Writers Digest has a lot of resources . I joined SCBWI , the Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators , and went to those conferences . I tried to find out how to be professional and I learned how to write a query letter . I learned how to write a first 30 that would grab somebody's attention and I learned to finish stuff . That was a big thing . A lot of people aspire to be writers and have a lot of half-finished books in their computer and that was me for a long time . And finally I realized if I'm going to be serious about this and get published , I actually have to commit to something , finish it , run it by friends and other readers who can help me and then revise it . That was another thing
Navigating the Publishing Industry
Speaker 3. I wasn't revising my own work for about 10 years after college . I would just be done and say for about 10 years after college it would just be done and say , great , it's finished . And you know , then I was actually at an SCBWI conference where I heard Linda Sue Park speak and Linda Sue Park won the Newbery Medal for a single shard and has a lot of terrific historical and contemporary kids' books and she was talking with her editor on the panel and they were talking about how they went through I don't know something like a hundred different edits on a book , you know , and by the time it was at the end it was very specific stuff . But she had a hundred different file files in the folder on her computer for the different revisions they had done and I was like I revised mine once before I sent it out and it really was very eye openingopening to me that if I was going to be a published author and build a career , that one of the things I was going to have to do was actually really pay attention to revision , to work really hard after the first draft was done to get it to a place where it was publishable . I love that . I persevered , I didn't quit .
Speaker 3Rejection is a part of the business and a lot of people are going to tell you no at every step of the way and you have to believe that you have a story that you want to tell and a voice that needs to be heard and you have to keep it up . You can't have just one idea , because if that idea , if nobody wants it , you go to the next one , you go to the next one . And , of course , another thing that has changed so much about the landscape of publishing is indie publishing and self-publishing . If that had been around when I was starting out 20 years ago , I might have taken some of the things that were turned down traditionally and tried to publish them .
Speaker 3Indie publishing or self-publishing it's just a whole different landscape and it's something I don't know much about now because I have a successful , traditionally published career . But I know people are doing great things there too . But regardless of whether you're trad publishing or whether you're indie publishing , I think the big thing is to keep producing work , to not produce one thing and then try to send it out for 10 years . Or don't keep revising something based on other people's feedback for 10 years . You've got to make it , revise it , try it out and if it doesn't float , try something new if you want to build a long-term career in publishing .
Speaker 2I love that . Out of curiosity , how does your agent-author relationship work with Holly ? Do you show her your ideas and you guys pick what she thinks will work ? Or do you give her proposals or do you write full manuscripts ? How do you guys decide what's going to be next ?
Speaker 3At this point my relationship with her is pretty easy Because I've published my last 10 or so books with Scholastic and really enjoy that partnership . We're not even shopping my next novel . Whatever I'm writing next , the assumption is that Scholastic is going to want it , and so what I'll do is I'll go to Holly and say , okay , the current contract we have is running out , here's the next book I'd like to write . But take this idea to Scholastic and see if they're interested and let's see if we can get . Usually I've had a multi-book deal where I'm doing two , three and the last contract was four books and we don't know what those next books are .
Speaker 3I don't write series , I write standalones now , and so my publisher and I don't know what my third book on a contract is going to be , except that it's probably going to be a historical thriller or a contemporary thriller , but it's going to be a middle-grade thriller and that has some sort of a social justice angle to it . That's another thing that I've tried to work into all of my recent books . So for me , I go to Holly and just say , hey , I just need your help to get this contract done , and she doesn't see my first drafts at this point and she doesn't really look at the revisions . She'll see the back and forth . We copy her , my editor and I copy her on everything . And she'll email me and say , do I need to read this one ? I'm like , no , not yet . It's got another couple of revisions , don't worry about it yet . But she always reads them . But she always , you know I always say don't bother with draft three if there's going to be seven drafts . You know so .
Speaker 3But when I started working with her I did have a book banned , this book that Scholastic wasn't as interested in because it didn't fit the other kind of books I'd been doing with Scholastic . They liked the book , but at the time I was really well-known for writing World War II thrillers and they were afraid that it would take me , that my audience wouldn't be as receptive to it and that it would take me farther away from where I was being successful . I still liked the book . I had written it in its entirety because it was kind of a side project . It wasn't something I had sold to a publisher . And so in a situation like that , holly will read the book , she'll talk to me about whatever changes I need to make that she advises After it goes through a little bit of revision . Then we talk about places that she thinks it would make a good home for it and sends it out .
Speaker 3I remember during that process we had a couple of good bites but they had other books about book banning in the works for middle grade readers and they didn't want to double up . They didn't want to compete with their own books . So some places that that book might have found a home took a pass , not because of the book necessarily , but because they already had something else that they were working on . I think right around the same time Chris Grabenstein was working on one of his Limoncello books and it was about like it had as a theme book banning in it and that publisher was like , oh , we love this , but we're doing Chris's book and it would compete with it . So it found a home at at at TOR's middle grade imprint at the time Starscape , where I'd already published a couple of things with them .
Speaker 3But that's usually what happens . If I have something that's not like a handed-off to Scholastic kind of thing , she and I will talk about it , talk about where it might work best and be best published , and then she does all the submitting and sends me feedback , whether it's a rejection or a success . I have tried writing a few things on the side , outside of the books that I write for Scholastic , and that's kind of the process with them . But for those I generally finish them first and take them to her to make sure that I'm committed enough to the project to actually see it through , because the Scholastic deadlines are fast and furious .
Speaker 2I love that . What was your biggest surprises or learning experiences about or in the industry ?
Speaker 3So initially I was very happy to get the phone call where somebody offered me a book deal and I was like , yeah , let's do it right on the phone . And that's not what you're supposed to do . You're supposed to say that sounds like a great offer . Let me get back to you . Of course that's when you're talking to an editor . If you're working with an agent already she's going to call you up and say I have an offer and you can discuss it on the phone right there . But I was so eager to have a book deal I was like , heck , yeah , let's do it . And then I went to find an agent and they're like , did you say yes on the phone ? And I was like , well , yeah , so it limited some of the things that they could negotiate , but what else do I ? Wish I had learned so at the beginning of my career .
Speaker 3I was really lucky enough to be able to write a lot of different genres . At the beginning of my career . I wrote historical fiction , I wrote contemporary fiction , I wrote mysteries , I wrote fantasies , penguin let me kind of feel my way into . They just said if it's a good book , we'll do it , and that worked . But it was hard to build sort of a brand identity , and I know that brand is a dirty word to a lot of creatives who just want to do whatever thing follow the art . And I get that . I totally get that . And I never write anything that I don't want to write . I never write anything for the market . That wasn't something that I was passionate about . That is a huge mistake . The book won't be good , you'll have a terrible time , it won't sell . I only write books that I want to write and that I'm excited about . Only write books that I want to write and that I'm excited about . But I wish that I had been able to think more . I wish I'd known more at the beginning that building a brand around the kind of books that you write is a really effective way to build a readership , and I think that people were picking up my early books because they were interested in that particular topic . Now , with my black and white and red books from Scholastic , I think it doesn't matter what the topic is . I think my readers are picking up because my name is on it , and that's a very different thing as an author If you can get to a place where they're picking up your book because of who you are and they're like well , I've read books by him before . I know I'm going to get a particular kind of experience out of it , an experience I love . That's where you really want to be , and so if there's a way to build a brand for yourself early on and it doesn't have to be narrow you don't have to say like I'm only going to write World War II thrillers because that's a nice niche , but it's really hard to keep that going . But saying like I'm going to write middle grade thrillers , set in any time and any place , is a lot more freeing but still is a brand . It still is a brand Like people know that when they pick my books up they're going to be page turners .
Speaker 3They know that when they pick them up I'm going to get right to the story right away , that there's going to be cliffhanger-y chapters and things that draw the reader forward , that the books aren't going to be super long . There's going to be , you know , like an expected amount of time that it will take to read it , which , when you're a kid I mean I don't know if you were like this when you were a kid , but most kids I know they look at a doorstopper and they're like no , I think I'll pass on the 600-page book and go for the one that's 250 . There are exceptions , obviously , and there are kids who will read anything that's that big . But there's a lot of reluctant readers out there who pick my books up because they know it would be a quick read and that it's something that they can actually make it through . So I've begun to think about all these different things that I'm known for and make sure that each of my projects fits within that expectation , and that's what I consider to be my brand .
Speaker 3Not only do the covers and the books look alike , but when you pick them up and read them , you're going to have an experience that you anticipated , that you expected and that you love . So if I could go back in time and tell my younger self what to do , I would say try to build a brand as early as you can .
Crafting Thrillers for Young Readers
Speaker 3I would also say start writing World War II thrillers as early as you can , but that's something that you can't know . What's going to click with kids or your audience , whoever your audience is but definitely trying to decide who you are as a writer and what you're trying to say as a writer , what you're trying to accomplish , and sometimes that may just be sheer entertainment , and you're just writing things that are just gonna be like the best , most awesome escapist read possible and that's terrific . Be known for that . Maybe you're gonna write books like mine that always have a social justice angle to them , so that that is always included and a teacher , for example , can know that if she puts that book into a kid's hands , that that's going to be an element of it as well , or that she may be able to use it in the classroom to teach larger stuff and that the book is going to be unputdownable .
Speaker 3But whatever your brand is , I was tutoring a young writer from Kentucky a few years back and she said I said why do you want to write ? What kind of stories do you want to tell ? And she said I want to show people that people from Appalachia aren't all rubes , that we aren't all the hillbilly stereotype . And I was like great , like you know what your vision is . Now , every story you tell , make sure that that's a part of it . And there's a myriad of stories that she could tell with that goal right . It doesn't limit her to genre . It doesn't limit her to time period . It doesn't limit her to what kind of character she writes about . But knowing why you write and having a goal with that is , I think , a terrific way to brand yourself . Even if you don't tell anybody else , you have a brand .
Speaker 2I love that . I absolutely love that . What makes a good thriller ?
Speaker 3I've thought a lot about this . What makes a good thriller ? I think short chapters , even for adults . I think if you pick up any James Patterson novel or any of the folks who write like him , you'll see short chapters . I think you will see action that is almost nonstop . You do have to have moments where your characters slow down and take a breath and reevaluate and analyze , but there's not a lot of how do I want to put it ? There's not a lot of looking backwards in the moment . There's a lot of just surviving and moving forward .
Speaker 3In a thriller , you may have time reflection is the word I want . There's not a lot of time for reflection in a thriller , in the middle of it , but what you want is for the end of it to when it wraps up . Then the characters can reflect on what happened , but in the moment there's a lot of moving forward and just responding and reacting . That a good thriller is one where the hero of your story learns what the problem is very early on and then spends the rest of the book trying to fix it . And whereas a mystery is , you know something mysterious has happened , Somebody's been murdered or a gem has been stolen or something and then you spend the rest of the time trying to figure out who done it . In a thriller , you know who did it and you know who , or you know who's going to do it . You know , like in the Day of the Jackal , that there is an assassin out there who is going to kill the president of France , and you have to stop it right .
Speaker 3And so a thriller needs to have , I think , a clearly defined goal at the beginning . I need to figure out X , I need to stop Y , I need to do Z , and that the whole rest of the book is the character following that . Now there may be twists and turns that take them off of that path and that send them in a new direction , and you need to have that . But they need to have an initial goal right from the start . Everybody else at my office has been killed while I was out to lunch , and now I'm on the run and I have to figure out why they targeted my office and why they're coming after me .
Speaker 3So , for me , a good thriller is one where I tell my young readers right off the bat this is what this story is going to be about , and then my main character has to keep confronting that problem all the way through the story until they solve that problem . And it has to be a fast read , super high pace . Cliffhanger chapters , as I've said before , really work in this kind of thing to keep pulling you forward and not a lot of reflection , like I said , Generally , what page does the action kick off for the thriller ?
Speaker 2Is it like a page one thing , a page five ?
Speaker 3You know . If you can do it on page one , it's awesome . But the problem with that is you usually don't know your character enough to care . So I always say by the end of the first chapter , like I really want to have a first chapter where we get to know my main character just a little bit , we get to know where we are and what's going on in the world , but then I we get to know where we are and what's going on in the world , but then I love to get to that inciting incident , as people often call it , their catalyst , by the end of the first chapter .
Speaker 3I learned a long time ago that , as a person who writes for kids , I think I have one of the most demanding audiences out there . You know , no kid ever said well , this book is really boring , but it got a great review in the New York Times , so I think I'm going to give it another hundred pages , right . Every kid has got video games that they want to play . They want to play outside . They've got other things to do besides read your book . A thousand other things calling for their attention their phones , their computers , their TVs , and I love all those things . I am not a kill your TV kind of guy . I just realized long ago that I have to compete with those things and that means that I have to use some of the same techniques . I use screenwriting books to write my stories . To help outline my stories , I watch television episodes with the clicker in hand and pause them after every scene to write down what happened in that scene and how long it took , so that I can analyze how television is feeding us stories , to think about how I can do that in my own books . It doesn't work exactly . It's apples and oranges , but you've got to understand how other stories are being fed to people on television and in film . And now people are writing books that you can read on your phone and they're designed to be short chapters and brief scenes where you're not lost in the middle of a long chapter , scrolling through with your thumb on the bus .
Speaker 3So for me , I realized with kids that I need to get to the story really , really quickly . I've got to be clear what the goals of the main character are and I need to get to those as early as possible , by the end of the first chapter , if possible . Sometimes I've got to go two chapters in , sometimes I've got to go three and it just kills me and I really , really want to get on with it . You know , I used to , when I started my career 20 years ago , tried to make sure that the inciting incident happened by page 30 . Now I'm trying to make sure it happens by page five or seven , and I just think that that's . It's both me learning more about how to write thrillers , but it's also , I think , just how we are changing as a society and demanding our speed in our stories .
Speaker 3If you watch a detective show from the 1970s , there are long sequences of people driving in cars just to get to where they're going , and it is boring , it is super boring . And if you watch a modern television show , the two cops will be in the police station and they'll say , hey , let's go interview this person . And then they cut and they are at the door of the person and they are asking that person questions . There's no driving . We don't care how they got there . We don't know . They might as well have teleported there for all we know . We never need to see it , we don't need to know it , and I think that a lot .
Speaker 3I think thrillers need to keep that in mind in books . I think thrillers need to keep that in mind . In books . I think it was Elmore Leonard who said all those boring parts in a book that you skip , don't write those . And I try to remember that . Don't write the boring parts . Get to the good stuff as soon as possible , and kids are a terrific audience for me for that . If they don't like where a book is going by page five , they will put it down and never come back , and so it's my job to make sure they don't put it down .
Speaker 2I love that you mentioned that you refer to some screenwriting books . To help you , what screenwriting books do you refer to ?
Speaker 3My biggest and
Story Structure and Character Introduction
Speaker 3best one is the old Save the Cat by Blake Snyder . That's my absolute favorite . After I read that book , I never viewed movies and any kind of story , honestly but movies for sure . The same way , I'm also a fan of I think it's Christopher Vogler who wrote the Hero's Journey for Writers , and the story goes that he was working as a story consultant at Disney and he wrote . He was like , do you guys know the Hero's Journey ? And they were like no . And so he wrote up a memo , like a nine page memo , about the hero's journey . And they and handed it to them and they were like this is gold . And if , apparently , from what I understand , they used it to write uh , the lion King and everything ever since then . And like some of the uh . This may be apocryphal , but somebody told me that when they got this nine page memo , when they read it , they kept locking it away in a vault , like in a safe . They didn't want anybody else to see it . And he's like guys , this is , this is the hero's journey , it's Star Wars , you know , like , like every like like this , I'm not the first , it's Joseph Campbell . You can go to the library and check this out .
Speaker 3But he ended up writing a book I believe it's called the Hero's Journey for Writers and I love that it's a much more in-depth book into all of the beats and tropes of the hero's journey and then translating them for contemporary storytelling . And then I mean in college I was brought up on Sid Field's screenplay . I mean that was one of the OG books that I read on story structure and that's the old just three-act structure . You know Blake Snyder and others have taken it and broken it down even farther so that you can see the different individual beats in something and the themes that you often get at the all is lost moment , the whiff of death , the turning points throughout a story . You know the point of the decision to act , all these kind of beats that I really think about when I'm creating a story .
Speaker 3Oftentimes those beats change in revision because as you revise a book and you rework your story you realize that some parts of it need to change it . You know , blake Snyder when he wrote that Save the Cat book was like on page 10 , this happens of your screenplay and on page 25 , this happens . And look , you can extrapolate for a novel . But it's really hard for those things to hit on exactly those pages . But if you use it as a guideline , boy , you can help build a strong story to start . Or if you don't like using structures like that to outline , if you're a pantser and you just want to sit down and go write your book , but then go back to it in the first revision and compare it to some of these structures and you can see in Ban this Book .
Speaker 3When I wrote my first two or three drafts , I shared them with other people , other writers I knew and something wasn't working right at the end of it . And one writer I knew , carrie Ryan , read it and she says , oh , you're missing an all is lost moment . They move right from planning the last , the big third act thing that they do , to doing it , and there's challenges there , but there's no all is lost moment . And I was like , oh gosh , you're right .
Speaker 3And so I added in a beat where they make all these plans and they do a whole lot of prep work , in a beat where they make all these plans and they do a whole lot of prep work and then the main character's little sister accidentally wrecks it , just like totally shreds it , like literally takes the big stack of paper and shreds it up to make fake hay for her , for her toy horses , and like then they have to scramble and it changed it , it , it , it created that oh no , we're , we're done .
Speaker 3It created that oh no , we're done , oh no . Moment that all is lost moment . And it helped me make a more dynamic climax to the book , as they have to scramble , to then rework their big plans and so , like I had already written , the put in one of these key beats that we , as savvy story consumers , all of us who read , who watch movies , who watch television , even if we don't know the names of them , even if we don't know how to structure a story , we're so brought up on stories that we know when something's missing and I think that's where books like Save the Cat or the Hero's Journey for Writers can really come in very helpful .
Speaker 2Love that , love that . What are the core elements of a good first page .
Speaker 3I think you got to get the main character and their name on the first page and we need to start seeing and hearing them from page one . I get really frustrated when I pick up a book and it's all the weather or the landscape and I'm a big Star Trek fan and I've read a lot of Star Trek novels and it's super like I never liked it when we started on an alien planet and it wasn't like my crew that I picked up the book to read . Like , the reader has particular expectations when they pick up a book and if the back cover says you're going to get Kirk
Crafting Strong Beginnings and Endings
Speaker 3and Spock on an adventure or your main character says this housewife is going to solve a murder , don't start somewhere else . Like , give me that character on page one and there's always time to back up , there's always time to flashback , there's always time to put something else in . But I think a lot of and this is an old Blake Snyder term the promise of the premise . I want some of the promise of the premise on page one and I think a little spectacle is great if you can do it so that you hook your reader in from the first moment . At the same time I have things that I don't want to do on page one . I do not want to introduce 10 characters on page one . No , no , no , no , no . Like it has to be one , maybe two characters that you introduce on page one , because nobody wants to pick up a book and have to think remember 10 names from page one . You've got to slowly introduce those things , so where we are , what's going on in this moment . You don't even have to give me the context .
Speaker 3I'm working on a book right now . That's about uh , it's a heist story set at the Berlin Olympics in 1936 . And I have my main character walking out of that tunnel into the stadium with all the cheering fans , with the American team , and Jesse Owens is right next to her and , like the Hitler's , up in the box watching over them . We get the feeling of where we are , but I don't have to . I don't need to tell you right now that we're not at war yet . I will tell you that later . I don't need to tell you right now what event she's in . I can tell you that later . I just need to set a really intriguing setting and put my main character in it and have them responding and thinking and being who they are in that moment .
Speaker 3I've seen a lot of books where they start out with like a bang . You know , a bang or a dragon eats somebody in the first line or something , and that's great , but we all haven't had time to care about the main character and you've got to . A story has to build , and if you start with a big bang , where do you go from there ? Then is it all a letdown until the very end , like that's also tricky . So I think the promise of the premise on page one , not too many characters , focusing though on the main character that's one of my pet peeves is when I pick up a book and the main character isn't on the first page or isn't even in the first chapter . Gosh , I want to get to them and I want to start identifying with them from page one .
Speaker 2So you're not a Harry Potter fan ? I take it .
Speaker 3I do not like the first chapter of Harry Potter . I was a huge Harry Potter fan when those books came out . I loved reading them . I have read them multiple times , read them to my own kid . Things are different now , obviously , but I have taught many classes on writing novels and I tell people , do not use the first Harry Potter novel as an example , do not . I don't like that . It starts without just not Harry , who's born of you , and Harry's a baby Like and it's on Privet Drive Like . It's this mysterious like . If I'm remembering correctly , it's like Hagrid on the motorcycle with the baby and McGonagall's there as a cat . There's so many characters that we're not going to meet again until he goes to school because we're going to be with the Dursleys for a little while and he's a baby Like . No , it's not my favorite opening .
Speaker 3I'll tell you another book that's terrific that has a bad first chapter . Maybe I shouldn't say this . The Ranger's Apprentice is another great book for young readers that has a terrible first chapter . I don't know what editor allowed this , but the whole first chapter is backstory . It's just like here's the history of this world and it's like oh my gosh , what seventh grader is going to read this . Then you get to the second chapter and the main character is climbing the outside of a building to spy on some adults who are getting ready to go on a big mission . That's awesome . That's a terrific first chapter . Why couldn't you start there and then drop in all that backstory stuff later on ?
Speaker 3I don't like prologues . Listen , I'll rant and rave . I'll get on my soapbox . I don't like prologues . I don't like starting with the character being born and I have some very rave . I'll get on my soapbox . I don't like prologues . I don't like starting with the character being born and I have some very favorite books that I've read that do this and I still I think it's a bad . I think it's a bad idea , especially for aspiring writers . You can maybe get away with that if you have 10 books out , because your reader will know to hang with you . And look , I know JK Rowling was unknown when that first book came out , but but I think it breaks a lot of the rules and I think that the best way to get published is to follow the rules as much as possible .
Speaker 3Your first time out like it's . It's very rare that a book that breaks the rules , it makes a . It becomes your first sale and that it becomes a breakout . Even three or four books into my career , I tried writing a book all in second person and it still got no traction . Nobody wanted it . I'd had two or three books out and they were like no , no , no , we're not doing a book in second person from you . Books out and they're like no , no , no , we're not doing a book in second person from you . Like maybe now that I've been on the New York Times bestseller list , I have 20 books out . If I said I'm going to write a book in second person , they might be like go for it , but four books and they were like oh no .
Speaker 2So you're right . Yeah , go ahead . I was just going to say you're right . It takes an established author with an audience to get away with that . For example , I love Stephen King , but I thought fairy tale took too long . I wanted the fairy tale and I couldn't wait for him to get in that shed and go where we wanted to go .
Speaker 3And that was what I was here for . But you know , as a Stephen King fan , that you're going to get it , yeah right , and so you'll hang with it .
Speaker 2But you know , as a Stephen King fan , that you're going to get it and so you hang with it . Right , because it was Stephen . I kept going , but anybody else I would have put the book down because I wouldn't have known that I would get the payoff I wanted .
Speaker 3That's what I'm saying . And so for the aspiring writers out there , it's really important to write the strongest first book that you can , and generally that means not breaking the rules . Doing something really creative within the rules is awesome . You know , I just read everybody in my family is a murderer and it's super clever and it's very fun and it very much plays by the rules . In fact , it lists the rules at the beginning of the book and then finds ways to have fun with those along the way . And so know the rules before you get into the rules of whatever genre you're writing , and obey them . Nobody wants your romance novel where there's not a happily ever after . Nobody wants that . So know what the tropes are and know what the unwritten rules are Sometimes they're actually written and do those and have fun within them with your early books . And then wait , save that great idea that you've got for a mind-breaking novel for later on when you've got an audience who will hang with you very true , very true .
Speaker 2How do you avoid the saggy middle ?
Speaker 3so for me a big breakthrough and I gosh , I wish I knew a book or something to recommend for this , but it's kind of just wisdom passed along by other authors . So I don't know if you've heard of the eight block . Have you heard people talk about an eight block in terms of writing ? Okay , I don't , I used to have . I moved I just moved to portland , like in april , and so I don't have my big board behind me , but I have a big board in my office that is a big rectangle that's squared off into eight different blocks and each of these blocks is a discrete section of my book . So the first two do I have . You know what ? I break down my book into eight different sections and each of these sections I have then assigned different parts of different like when I use Blake Snyder's Save the Cat , I assign different parts of his Save the Cat to these different eight blocks .
Speaker 3So the first block is the introduction , where we meet the main character and see the ordinary world . The line
Crafting Compelling Story Structure
Speaker 3between the first and second block that come on top of each other in a column is where the instigating moment happens , the catalyst happens , the inciting incident , and the main character has a choice to make . Do I go off on the adventure or do I stay home ? Luke Skywalker finds out from Obi-Wan Kenobi that he needs to go save a princess . Well , actually so , and will I leave ? And then there's a decision to be made , and the decision to act is that next block . And then at the bottom of that , the very bottom of this first column , that's when the main character decides I'm going to go after the adventure . And when they move from that they move into the second act . And for me , the second act is the four middle blocks . So I've got the blocks go 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 . So there's eight blocks . It's like a rectangle and you divide it long ways in half and so you've got four columns of two blocks each , and the first two blocks are the first act . The next four in the middle are the second act . And the way that I make sure I don't have a saggy middle is I make sure that I think about my second act as four different sections , so that something interesting and exciting happens in each of those four sections . So that something interesting and exciting happens in each of those four sections , because a lot of times people won't break up that big act two . They'll just get into it and start writing . But I have to say like , okay , borrowing from Blake Snyder again , block three is the fun and games moment . This is where we have the movie poster .
Speaker 3If you're reading Wizard of Oz , block three is Dorothy's first time exploring Oz . She's walking down that yellow brick road . This is where Luke goes off into space and sees aliens and all kinds of weird stuff for the first time . Right , he's not on Tatooine anymore . Then that next block down I think of as like the X Games , and something more extreme happens . And then block five is the bad guys close in and block six is all is lost and block seven is the climax . But now we're into act three .
Speaker 3So that middle part though to get back to your question , act two for me is twice as long as act one and it's twice as long as act two . It's like act two itself is if you added the material in act one and act three together . So you've got a long middle part of your story , and what I want to do is make sure that there's always that I break it down into four different pieces and I think about those as set pieces , like people do in movies . This set piece is going to be where they are escaping from this building . And this set piece is going to be where they're now . They are in a helicopter and the helicopter is low on fuel and has a bullet hole in it . It's trying and they have to make sure it doesn't crash . And here they crash land . And now they're being chased on the ground by FBI agents . And now , here in the all is lost moment , the main character's mentor has been killed and they have to go alone into the third act . So for me and this is a very complicated answer , I know I'm sorry , but the second act has to be broken up into pieces .
Speaker 3If you don't break your second act up into pieces , you will find yourself writing one big , long slog , and that's where the middle of the book begins to sag .
Speaker 3So I break my second act up into four pieces and after the first two of those pieces , something really big happens .
Speaker 3This is the midpoint of the book and something really big has to happen . I always go back to movie examples or old literature examples , but this is where Bilbo goes into the cave and comes out with the ring after having the contest with Gollum and almost being eaten by Gollum . There's this big moment in the middle and he comes out and now it's a race to the finish of the story . So for me , I always look for that . People will call it a tentpole moment , some people call it the point of no return but something massive happens in the middle of right in the middle of the story . But in addition to that , I want to make sure that the buildup to it has steps and leaving that moment has more steps . So I break my second act into four pieces and make sure that something exciting happens in each of those pieces and that the end of each of those pieces is a turning point for the story , with the biggest turning point of all those being the midpoint of the whole book .
Speaker 2Love that , and how do you craft a compelling end ?
Speaker 3Oh , conclusions are hard For me . I've started thinking about what's the one thing my main character would never do when the book begins and then make them do it in the third act . That's maybe as simple an answer as I can give you . But if your character literally got burned they were in a house fire and they were afraid of fire and they have avoided any kind of flames all their lives then in the third act you've got to put them in a burning building and they've got to do something heroic when that place is burning down . And that's the simplest example I can give .
Speaker 3Establish right away from your first chapters what your main character would never do . Sometimes it's a physical wound like that . Sometimes it's a mental wound , like you know . In romance stories this is I'll never love again . I've been burned or I watched my mom get burned by a bad relationship and I will never love again . And the finale of a romance is a character finding love . So what is it that your main character swears they will not ever do at the beginning ? Make them do it in the finale , and I think that's a really satisfying thing to do and can help you come up with a good ending . If you know your main character is afraid of fire . You know what the setting has got to be for that climax . It's got to be in a burning building or something , a forest fire you know out in . You know in California or Oregon or something , or or if it's a romance to take it away from , like an epic story or a or a violent story , I will never , I will never love anybody , ever again . And then you know how it ends . They're going to fall in love in that , in that final act . They're going to . They've been falling in love all through your book . They're going to fall in love in that final act . They've been falling in love all through your book . They're going to accept that they have fallen in love and they're going to commit to being in love in that final act . So for me , the climax has got to pay off , something that you see very early on . I also believe that a really good story should not end where you promised you'd begin . In terms of the external plot , let me say that better .
Speaker 3In Star Wars , luke goes off to save the princess . He does that by the middle of the movie . That's not the climax of the movie . He and Ben Kenobi save Princess Leia by the middle of the movie . The thing is that when they come out she has the plans to the Death Star , and now the story shifts and because you did that , now there's something new to do . At the end she says , well , great , now that you've saved me , we need you and all these other pilots to go destroy the Death Star , and that becomes the big third act .
Speaker 3So I often tell aspiring writers don't tell me from page one that the goal for your main character is to destroy the Death Star . They don't know that yet . They have goals along the way and each time they achieve those goals their larger goal changes . The biggest goal for Luke is to become a Jedi , is to accept his destiny as a hero and to embrace the Force . And that's what happens when he blows up the Death Star .
Speaker 3He turns off the targeting computer and he uses the force and he blows up the Death Star , and so the story is about him embracing the force , and the external stuff we've done to get there is to build him up to where he has to use it to destroy the Death Star . So I always say start off with a really clear goal in chapter one , if you can , and then , at each of the stages of the story , as you move along , as those things are accomplished , keep changing that goal and keep raising the stakes . And so by the end , you are forcing your character to do one thing that they never thought they would do . Luke accepts himself as a hero and closes his eyes and shoots , and at the beginning he would never have thought he was capable of that , never believed he could do that . So make your character do something they would never do and raise the stakes until there's no other choice but to do it .
Speaker 2I love that . I love that . Any advice for aspiring authors .
Speaker 3Read a lot . I've run into so many aspiring authors who have great story ideas but they're not reading what they want to write . And I run into especially a lot of kids book authors and I'll say do you can name one book that's on the New York Times bestseller list for middle grade ? And they can't do it and look , that's fine , there are plenty of books that aren't going to ever hit the New York Times bestseller list . But I think you got to know what's big and what kids are reading right then and decide do you want to write that or do you want to write something else , and be okay with that . I know a lot of people who bristle about their low sales and I'm like but look at the book you wrote , it's not , it's not a big breakout commercial book . You can't . And the book they wrote is fine , it's great , it may even win an award of some kind , but you , but you can't . You can't expect tremendous commercial results if you don't study the market . So I would say read a lot , read the kind of books that you want to write , to help understand how those books are written , so that your book can be a part of that like on that part of the shelf , but also so you can temper your expectations , so you can know what could potentially happen with your book . Are you writing a book that could break out ? Then look at the book . Do you want your book to break out ? Then look at the books that have broken out and study them .
Speaker 3When I started writing my fantasy novel , I picked up the Rick Riordan books and I read them one straight through , and then I went back and reread them and broke them down chapter by chapter , and tried to see where the story beats happened . I tried to see what he was doing with his characters . I tried to learn from somebody who was already successful . Study the work of people who are already successful . I laugh with my agent all the time .
Speaker 3I do not understand why there are not more authors doing exactly what I'm doing . Like a lot of times kids will say what other books can I read ? And I have a handful of authors that I point them to , but I don't know why there aren't 30 people doing what I'm doing . And maybe it's just because it's just what I'm most interested in and they're not . But it also could be and they're not , but it also could be that they're just not reading my books I try to keep up with the Joneses and know what they're doing and always be learning and that kind of thing . So read what you want to write . I think that's a super basic , but a lot of people skip that step because they just want to jump into the writing .
Speaker 2Love it , love it , love it . How can people connect with you ?
Speaker 3You can find me at my website , which is alangratscom , and I have a sub stack which you can also subscribe to that . That is an e-newsletter that will come out and tell you where I'm at and what I'm doing . I've really pulled back from social media . I'm on Twitter and I'm on Instagram . I can tell you those , but I really don't update those . I got off Twitter a long time ago . Instagram just kind of feels like a time suck . I've got other reasons for being off of Twitter . You can probably guess that , but those are the places I would prefer people find me . So , yes , it's allangratzsubstackcom , so either allangratzcom or substackallangratzcom , and I link to that on my webpage .
Speaker 4That wraps up today's Craft Chat Chronicles with JD Mayor . Thanks for joining us . If you liked the episode , please comment , subscribe and share . For show notes , writing workshops and tips , head to jdmayorcom . That's jdmayorcom . While you're there , join JD's mailing list for updates , giveaways and more .